Live Nibley listings, filtered
Nibley homes under $500K
Every Nibley home for sale under $500K is on this page, whichever brokerage holds the listing, and the MLS keeps it current. Below the list, I cover what that money buys in Nibley and how a purchase here tends to go.
This page
- Filter
- Price under $500,000
- Area
- Nibley, UT
- Sort
- Newest first
- Feed
- Wasatch Front Regional MLS, live
Want it narrower? Tell me your exact spec.
The newest listings under $500K
Listing information comes from the Wasatch Front Regional Multiple Listing Service and is deemed reliable but not guaranteed.
Part 1 of 3
Where Under $500K sits
The local read, the median line and the pricing tiers
The local read
Under $500K is where Nibley starts
In shortThe U.S. Census puts the typical Nibley home value near $461,100, and that figure falls inside this page. It is the lowest Nibley price page, and it holds three kinds of home, from townhome-style homes to newer detached houses. The MLS feeds this list live, newest homes first.
Start with the number. The typical Nibley home value is about $461,100 (U.S. Census ACS 2020-2024), and that figure falls inside this page. This is also the lowest Nibley price page. About three in four Nibley homes were built in 2000 or later, so a newer detached home is the realistic expectation here.
Most current building is on the 1200 West side, where Nibley Meadows, Hawk Hollow and Heritage Crossing carry the newer plans. Townhome-style homes, about 9% of Nibley homes and most of them built in the last few years, are found at this price too. The older core along Main Street and 3200 South, near City Hall, adds older houses.
A newer home near the Nibley trails still draws attention in season. Staying ready with a pre-approval keeps the timing in your hands rather than the market's.
Sorting out the price ranges? The under $600K page is the next step up, and the cost of living page sets the wider budget picture. When a listing looks right, reach out to get more detail.
Stretch math
One step up
under $600K adds bigger plans, many with a third bay in the garage or a bonus room.
The lowest range
This is the lowest Nibley price page, so the choice is about the kind of home. You can pick a newer detached house, a townhome-style home, or a house in the older core.
Either way
If a townhome-style home or an older core house fits your list, stay here. If you need a third garage bay, step up a page.
How this works. Scott Buehler is licensed in both real estate and mortgage lending and may assist with financing across Utah; local representation in Nibley comes through a partner agent. Every role is disclosed, and you are always free to choose your own agent and your own lender. More on How I Work.
The median line
Where under $500K falls among Nibley home values
The Nibley typical home value of ~$461,100 falls inside under $500K. Read the bar from left to right, cheapest page first. Gold marks the stretch this page covers. A thin line marks the typical home value.
The pricing tiers
Which Nibley price range fits your budget?
Pick any of the four pages below to see a different slice of Nibley. Every page carries live listings and a local read written for it. The page you have open is the lit one.
Under $500K
NibleyUnder $600K
One step upSee homes under $600KUnder $700K
Two steps upSee homes under $700KOver $700K
The top of the marketSee homes over $700KOr set your own filters
All Nibley homes plotted on one mapChoose your own price, number of beds and baths, and kind of home, and each match shows up on the map. Looking around needs no account.Open the map searchPart 2 of 3
What the money buys
What the money buys, stretch up, or hold here and the towns next door
What the money buys
Under $500K comes in three shapes
No Nibley price page sits lower than this one. Almost everything here is one of three kinds of home, and knowing which you want focuses the search.
Newer plans on the 1200 West side
Mid-size detached homes in Nibley Meadows, Hawk Hollow and Heritage Crossing, where most current building happens. Plans are newer, and lots run close to a third of an acre, which is the Nibley norm.
The catch: you are buying where building is still going on, so expect construction nearby. The upside: newer construction and low near-term upkeep.
Townhome-style homes
About 9% of Nibley homes are townhome style, and most were built in the last few years. The city permitted 107 attached homes in 2024 alone.
What you get: a newer home with less yard to care for. The catch: less land and shared walls.
Houses in the older core
Homes along Main Street and 3200 South, near City Hall, are the oldest part of town. Few Nibley homes date from before 1980, so even the older core is not old by most towns' standards.
The downside: updates that vary from house to house. The payoff: Anhder Park and the City Center Bike Park close by.
Which of these three kinds of home is for sale changes from week to week. The list above shows what is available today, and the Homes for Sale page shows all of Nibley.
Stretch up, or hold here
What each price range buys
Each price page leans toward a different kind of home. The columns below show what changes as the cap moves up. You are reading the first column now.
| Comparison point | Under $500K This page | Under $600K | Under $700K |
|---|---|---|---|
| Typical home shape | Mid-size newer plans on the 1200 West side, townhome-style homes and older core houses | Larger plans with a third garage bay, or a lot backing onto the wetlands | Wider lots out on the south and west edges |
| What you usually give up | A bigger plan, and a lot that backs onto open space | Some savings, since bigger plans cost more | A much larger budget, well above the typical Nibley home value |
| What you usually gain | Three kinds of home at the lowest cap | More room inside, often with a third garage bay | A wider lot and more space between houses |
| Where these homes sit | Nibley Meadows, Hawk Hollow, Heritage Crossing and the older core along Main Street | Bigger plans in those same 1200 West streets, plus homes near the wetlands | Out toward the south and west edges of town |
| What to check | Check what is still being built on the street | Check what the lot backs onto | Check the canal shares and the land next door |
Your must-haves decide which column fits. Tell me what they are and I will point you to the right page.
The towns next door
What does under $500K buy in the towns next door?
Price pages also exist for the towns around Nibley. The chart shows where under $500K falls in the four nearest towns that have them, and which page to open in each.
On this chart, the gold line marks the cap for this page, Under $500K.
Each figure comes from that town's own price page, and its source is listed. Drive times are from the Utah drive times tool.
Part 3 of 3
Buying at the lowest cap
A four-step play
A four-step play
How to buy at the lowest cap
The lowest price page rewards people who are ready. Get your paperwork in order and your wish list written down before you start touring.
Get pre-approved first
A pre-approval letter shows a seller you can get a loan. Get it before you fall for a house, so a good listing does not catch you unprepared.
Pin your must-haves early
Name the one or two things driving the search: a single-level plan, a specific community, trail access. Then you are not choosing again at each showing.
Turn on listing alerts
Builders on the 1200 West side keep adding homes. An email the day one lists means you see each new one.
Learn the steps ahead of time
Learn the steps before the right home lists. The buying process guide and the guide to making an offer explain each one in plain words.
Client reviews
What a past client said
These are real reviews from past clients, shown as they wrote them.
Posted by past clients on Google and Experience.com.
If you want a very competent, knowledgeable, personable, honest realtor, who has your back every step of the way, Scott is your guy! He leaves no stone unturned and genuinely has your best interests in mind at all times. He communicates every move. Working with Scott definitely made this the easiest and most stress free real estate transaction that I have ever experienced!! Thank you, Scott!!
Quick answers
Under $500K in Nibley, answered
Mostly newer detached houses on the 1200 West side, in Nibley Meadows, Hawk Hollow and Heritage Crossing, along with townhome-style homes and houses in the older core. Today's homes are in the list above.
Yes, by a little. The U.S. Census puts the typical Nibley home value near $461,100, so a $500K cap sits just above it. That number is what owners say their homes are worth, so it is not a sale price.
Heritage Elementary, at 925 West 3200 South, serves the west and south of town, including City Hall. Every Nibley address goes to Maple View Middle and Ridgeline High. The district redrew some lines for 2026 to 2027, so check the district map for the exact address.
Detached homes are far more common. The Census counts about 90% of Nibley homes as single-family houses and about 9% as townhome-style homes. Most of the townhomes were built in the last few years.
Ask when the roof, furnace and water heater were last replaced, since updates vary from house to house. Also ask what the lot backs onto. Few Nibley homes date from before 1980, so the older core is not as old as in many towns.
Check what is still being built nearby. J Thomas Homes and Kartchner Homes are both building on that side in 2026, so a street can stay a work site for a while. Ask the city planner where each new plan stands.
Talk to Scott
Starting your Nibley search at the lowest cap?
Newer plans on the 1200 West side, townhome-style homes and the older core all sit on this page. The local partner agent knows which communities are still selling, which streets are being built, and which listings are worth the drive.
How it works in Nibley
- A second set of eyes.Spotted a Nibley home that looks right? Forward it to me. I check with the partner agent and then tell you what to look at before an offer is written.
- Someone local at the showing.A partner agent I trust in Cache Valley takes you through the tours, the offer and the closing. I make the introduction.
- A lender's view, too.I am licensed in both real estate and lending. On any one purchase I take one role. If I am your lender, I can flag early when a loan on a home may be hard to get.
- Answers within a business day.Call or text me about any home on this page, and I write back within one business day.
Or call me: (435) 357-4345I reply within one business day.
Referral disclosure. Outside Southern Utah, I connect home sellers and buyers with partner agents I trust in their area. If you choose to work with an agent I refer, that agent's brokerage pays my brokerage (Real Broker, LLC) a referral fee. The fee comes out of the agent's compensation; it is not an added cost to you. You are always free to choose any agent you wish, and using a referred agent is never required.