Skip to content

The Local

Before it was Salem Salem

Fourteen years under a name that described exactly what was there

Pond Town, and the century before the name changed

Two men dammed a spring fed stream in 1851 and the settlement took the pond's name for the next fourteen years. A fort went up in 1856 and a monument marked its site in 1938. A canal surveyed with a two by four and a cup of water ran river water into the fields from 1869. And a mill built in 1932 still stands on the hillside east, privately owned, having processed almost nothing at all.

Scott BuehlerBy Scott Buehler, Moving Utah Updated October 2026

Start here


For fourteen years this place was simply called Pond Town

In 1851 David Fairbanks, who had been Payson's first bishop, and David Crockett located land at a spring fed stream at the head of the water that is now in the middle of Salem. They dammed it, which raised the level enough to run water into irrigation ditches, and the pool that resulted gave the settlement the only name anybody needed for the next fourteen years. It was Pond Town, and the pond was the whole argument for being there.

The name recorded for the site in the Ute language is Summer Spring, which is a more evocative description of the same fact. It is worth stating plainly that Summit Creek, a name that turns up attached to Salem in careless write ups, has nothing to do with this town at all. That is the original name of Santaquin, further along the valley, and confusing the two makes a hash of both histories.

The renaming came in 1865, when the townsite was surveyed. Lyman Curtis proposed Salem after his Massachusetts hometown, and the town has carried the City of Peace epithet ever since. Accounts differ on whether that hometown was Salem or New Salem, both in Massachusetts, so Massachusetts is as precise as anyone needs to get.

Pond Town, in dates

1851

the springs located and dammed

1865

renamed Salem when the townsite was surveyed

1886

incorporated as a town

10 May 1920

a city, when the first mayor took office

The fort


A monument from 1938 standing on ground you can pace out

The single best ten minutes of history in this town is a pair of markers near the pond, at roughly 99 South 300 West. One was put up by the Daughters of Utah Pioneers on 16 July 1938 to mark the site of the Pond Town Fort. The other records the town's first post office. Between them they carry the names, the dates and the dimensions.

The factWhat the record saysWhy it still shows
Who located the landDavid Fairbanks and David Crockett, in 1851, at a stream running from the springsThe dam they built is the reason there is a pond rather than a marsh
Who built the fortEli Ashcraft, Royal Durfey, Silas Hillman, Aquilla Hopper, Jacob Killian and Truman Tryon, with their families, from 1856The first dozen or so households of the town, named on a marker rather than lost
How big it wasRoughly 160 feet north to south by 150 feet east to west, enclosed by the autumn of 1858Small enough to walk the footprint of in the park in about two minutes
Why it was builtRaiding in this part of the valley had already pushed nearby settlers behind wallsIt is why the town's oldest ground is clustered rather than strung out
How long it lastedIn regular use until about 1870, after which families moved into ordinary housesThe original core blocks around the pond are what people moved out into
Who marked itThe Daughters of Utah Pioneers, on 16 July 1938, alongside a first post office markerIt is the only public interpretation of its own history that Salem has

Every name, date and dimension above is carved on the two markers by the pond, which makes them the shortest way to read the town's founding: about ten minutes, standing on the ground it happened on. The wording is of its time, 1938, and reads that way, but the dates hold up against the standard histories of the town.

Incorporation came in two steps and it is worth not compressing them, because plenty of summaries do. Salem became a town in 1886 and was run by fourteen town boards over the next thirty four years. It became a city on 10 May 1920, on the day its first mayor took office. Anyone who tells you the town was incorporated in 1920 has skipped a third of a century of local government.

The other date worth carrying is 1916, when the Orem Interurban railway line ran through the town. An electric interurban through a farming community of that period is the arrival of the outside world on a timetable, and it belongs in any account of how a pond settlement turned into somewhere people commuted from.

The canal


Surveyed with a two by four and a cup of water for a level

The pond made the town possible and the canal made it viable. In the autumn of 1865 Lyman Curtis and his brothers set out to survey a line that would bring Spanish Fork River water down to the Pond Town farms, and the instrument they used for it was a length of two by four with a cup of water sitting on it. That is the whole survey kit. Water first ran in the summer of 1869.

It is easy to read that as folklore and it is worth reading it as engineering instead. A cup of water on a straight edge is a working level, it will tell you which way a line falls, and over the distance involved it produced a canal that carried river water to a set of fields four years later. Later on, Strawberry Valley Project water supplemented what the local system could deliver.

That canal is not a museum piece. The chain that runs from it is the reason a Salem address today has two water systems rather than one: the city built a pressurized irrigation network in 2008 drawing on non potable canal water, specifically so that groundwater could be kept for indoor use, and it metered every connection on that system from 2023 under a state mandate. The 1865 survey and the 2023 meter are the same story at two ends.

A length of two by four, a cup of water, and four years later a river was running through somebody's field. Salem still runs on that decision.

The mill on the hillside


The strangest thing you can see from anywhere in this town

Look east from the pond and there is a white concrete building high on the mountainside. It is a mill, it was built in 1932, it has processed almost nothing in its entire existence, and the story attached to it is one of the most remarkable in Utah. It is also private property, and that part is not negotiable.

The diggings began in September 1894, after John Hyrum Koyle said he had been shown the location and the contents of an ore body in a dream. The enterprise was incorporated in 1909. In 1932 the shareholders, most of them in the middle of a depression, raised the money for a state of the art mill near the mouth of the tunnel to process the outpouring of gold the visions had promised, and the building that resulted is the white structure on the mountainside.

It went into operation in 1936 and, in the whole span since, has processed a single load of ore, which netted the company one hundred and three dollars and three cents. The enterprise was reorganized as the Relief Mine Company in 1961 and the company still holds annual shareholder meetings that draw hundreds of people. Ninety years after the mill was built, the shares are still held and the meeting still happens.

It is a genuinely extraordinary thing to have on a skyline and it is not a place to visit. The company owns the ground, the mine, the mill and houses around them, and the road up is part of that. It earns a place here because you can see it from the middle of the town and will inevitably ask what it is, and because a landmark you can see from a public park is a fair subject. Standing in front of it is not.

The Dream Mine is private property in its entirety, including the road up to it. The Relief Mine Company owns the mine, the 1932 mill and the buildings around them on the mountainside east of Salem, and none of it is open to the public. It is not a ghost town, it is not an abandoned site and it is not an urban exploration destination, whatever a video suggests: it is a working corporate landholding with a shareholder base that still meets annually. Look at it from the valley floor, which is where the view is best in any case, and read the story rather than driving toward it. Trespass on a site like this is a straightforward legal problem and a genuine safety one.

Quick answers


Pond Town, answered

Because the pond came first and the settlement grew around it. In 1851 David Fairbanks, who had been Payson's first bishop, and David Crockett located land at a spring fed stream and dammed it, raising the water enough to run into irrigation ditches. The pool that formed was the reason to be there and it gave the place its working name for the next fourteen years. The name recorded for the site in the Ute language is Summer Spring.

In 1865, when the townsite was surveyed. The settler Lyman Curtis proposed Salem after his Massachusetts hometown, and the town has used the City of Peace epithet ever since. Accounts differ on whether that hometown was Salem or New Salem, both in Massachusetts, so Massachusetts is as precise as it gets. One thing Salem was never called is Summit Creek: that is the original name of Santaquin, further along the valley, and the two are regularly confused.

A defensive enclosure built around the settlement's first dozen or so families. Construction began in 1856 after raiding in this part of the valley had already pushed nearby settlers behind walls, it was enclosed by the autumn of 1858, and it measured roughly 160 feet north to south by 150 feet east to west. It stayed in regular use until about 1870, after which families moved out into ordinary houses. The Daughters of Utah Pioneers marked the site on 16 July 1938.

Near the pond, at roughly 99 South 300 West, in the park ground a visitor has probably already parked beside. The Daughters of Utah Pioneers erected it on 16 July 1938 and a marker recording the town's first post office stands alongside it. Together they take about ten minutes to read and they carry the names of the men who located the land in 1851 and of the families who built the fort five years later, plus the fort's dimensions and the renaming.

In two steps, and compressing them into one date is a common error. Salem was incorporated as a town in 1886 and was run by fourteen town boards over the following thirty four years. It became a city on 10 May 1920, the day its first mayor took office. So a summary that gives 1920 as the incorporation date has quietly skipped a third of a century of local government, which for a settlement founded in 1851 is a substantial omission.

The channel that brought Spanish Fork River water to the Pond Town farms. Lyman Curtis and his brothers surveyed the line in the autumn of 1865 using a length of two by four with a cup of water on it for a level, and water first ran in the summer of 1869. Strawberry Valley Project water later supplemented what the local system could deliver. The canal is also the ancestor of the pressurized irrigation network the city built in 2008 and metered from 2023.

A mine and a white concrete mill on the mountainside east of the town, begun in September 1894 after John Hyrum Koyle said he had been shown an ore body in a dream. The enterprise was incorporated in 1909, the mill was built in 1932 by shareholders raising money in the middle of a depression, and it went into operation in 1936. In all that time it processed a single load of ore, netting the company one hundred and three dollars and three cents.

No. The Relief Mine Company, which the enterprise was reorganized as in 1961, owns the mine, the mill and the buildings around them on the mountainside, and the road up is part of that holding. It is not a ghost town, an abandoned site or an urban exploration destination; it is a working corporate landholding whose shareholders still hold annual meetings drawing hundreds of people. The view from the valley floor is the best one available in any case, and it is the only one that is lawful.

Yes. The Orem Interurban line ran through the town from 1916, which for a farming community of that period meant the outside world arriving on a timetable rather than on a horse. That matters more to the town's shape than it might sound: an electric interurban is what turns a settlement people were born and buried in into a place people can commute from, and Salem's transition from a pond and canal farming town toward a valley address begins around there.

Scott Buehler, Moving Utah

A dam, a fort, a canal and a mill that never paid

History explains why the old blocks around the pond are laid out the way they are, and it does not tell you what a parcel there carries today. Those are different questions: whether a street is on the original core or on the ground added since, what a lot's position is on the pressurized irrigation system, and how the growth on the south and west sides is changing the streets between them. Tell me what you are weighing and I will put you with a Utah County partner agent who works this end of the valley, and stay on the file for the financing side.

Or call Scott: (435) 357-4345or send Scott a message

Keep going


Continue your Salem research

Eight more doors into Salem, chosen for what this page covers.

Scott Buehler

Questions about Salem?

Call Scott, send a message, or find out what your Salem home is worth. No pressure, no obligation.

Referral Disclosure: For moves outside Southern Utah, I can connect you with trusted local agents. If you choose to work with one, their brokerage pays my brokerage (Real Broker, LLC) a referral fee from their commission. This costs you nothing extra, and you are never obligated to use my referral.