Skip to content

Pros and cons

By Scott BuehlerUpdated November 2026

Pros and cons of living in Providence

About half of Providence's homes have five bedrooms or more, the city owns a fiber network, and Logan's Main Street is about 4 minutes from City Hall. A Census value over the county's, high radon tests, hazard maps on the east edge and a floodway along Spring Creek sit on the other side.

In its favor: 6To weigh: 6Jump to the verdict

Is Providence, Utah a good place to live?

The short answerProvidence gives you big houses, a share of homes built since 2020 that is more than twice the county's, a fiber network the city owns and Logan's Main Street minutes away. Its Census value runs over the county's and Logan's, few homes are rented, about 65 in 100 radon tests read high, the east edge carries a fault and old landslides, Spring Creek crosses town as a floodway, and Salt Lake City is about an hour and a half away over one mountain pass.

Providence sits in the Cache County School District, not Logan's. For 2026-27 the line runs from Providence Elementary to the new Maple View Middle in Nibley and on to Ridgeline High in Millville, about 5 minutes away. The north end maps to River Heights Elementary, and Spring Creek Elementary is a K-5 Spanish and French immersion magnet. The district redrew its lines in September 2025, and its boundary map shows the school for each address. GreatSchools and Niche publish the scores and reviews.

The town counted about 9,540 people in 2025, up about 16 percent from the 2020 base. Yard water comes through mutual water companies, not the city, and shares in them do not pass with a deed on their own, so ask for the paperwork on any shares, including the yearly assessment (irrigation water shares).

Across the valley

Bedrooms by city, the rate list and three mapped parts of town

The Census table puts Providence's value over Logan's and level with North Logan's, and the state's rate report puts its city rate in the valley's middle.

Seven big cities and the county

Only Hyde Park matches Providence on five-bedroom houses

Census ACS 2020 to 2024

Providence's Census value sits above the county's, Logan's, Smithfield's and Hyrum's, and level with North Logan's, Hyde Park's, Nibley's and Utah's. Its five-bedroom share is level with Hyde Park's and well above the rest.

Providence's 12.3 percent built in 2020 or later is more than twice the county's 4.7. Smithfield's 7.4 and Hyde Park's 7.3 sit inside its margin of error, so none of the three can be called the newest.

Census ACS 2020 to 2024 figures, Providence, six big neighbors and the county
PlaceHome valueValue to incomeFive bedrooms or moreBuilt 2020 or laterRented homes
Providence$515,9004.452.4%12.3%14.5%
Logan$383,6006.38.3%3.7%62.8%
Hyrum$422,6004.821.8%7.2%16.6%
Smithfield$450,2004.635.3%7.4%19.5%
Nibley$461,1004.329.2%5.8%6.2%
North Logan$492,6005.529.6%5.1%40.3%
Hyde Park$573,9005.153.7%7.3%9.3%
Cache County$444,4005.423.5%4.7%36.3%

Local tip. Providence added about 16 people for every 100 it counted in 2020, while the county added about 9.

City rates and hearings

Fourth of seven big city rates, with the school line the one up for a raise

Utah State Tax Commission report, 2025 rates; 2026 Truth in Taxation list

On the state's 2025 report, Providence's city rate is ninth highest of the 19 cities and towns in Cache County. Among the seven big cities it is fourth, in the middle. North Logan's is a hair above it.

No property tax increase hearing appears in the city's 2026 notices. The Cache County School District, the biggest line on a Providence bill, did hold one, and this page does not have the vote. Only city lines are compared here, so nothing on it describes a total bill.

Seven big cities' 2025 city rates set beside Providence's, with the 2026 hearing list
PlaceCity rate against Providence'sOn the 2026 hearing list
NibleyHigherNo
SmithfieldHigherNo
North LoganHigherYes
ProvidenceThe referenceNo
Hyde ParkLowerYes
LoganLowerYes
HyrumLowerNo

Local tip. Garbage pickup has used city-owned trucks since 2024.

Three parts of town

The east hillside, the creek blocks and the west edge each carry their own maps

USGS, Utah Geological Survey and FEMA maps; Utah DEQ radon 2019

The hillside has the fault, the study zone, the slides and the fans. The creek blocks have the floodway. The far west edge has the second Zone AE strip and the higher water table.

Radon is reported by ZIP code, and 84332 covers Providence. It ran 64.9 in 100 short-term tests at or above 4 pCi/L, over the county's 51.7 and Utah's 35.4.

What the maps show in each part of Providence
Part of townWhat the maps show
East hillside, about 4,850 to 5,250 feetEast Cache fault zone, state fault study zone, seven old landslides, alluvial fans, state wildlife land at the boundary
North-central blocks, about 300 East to Highway 165Spring Creek floodway, Zone AE, past Gateway Drive and City Hall
Far west edgeZone AE, with wetlands, open waterways and a higher water table noted by city staff in July 2026

Local tip. An alluvial fan from Spring Creek also spreads through the middle of town.

NextHouses, fiber, Logan, the city rate and Zollinger

In its favor

Houses, fiber, Logan, the city rate and Zollinger

Things a buyer can see on a tour or plug in on the first day.

Space

How big are the houses in Providence?

In shortAbout half of Providence's homes have five bedrooms or more, against about a quarter across Cache County. About 7 in 10 have at least four.

The Census counts 1,497 of the town's roughly 2,856 homes with five bedrooms or more, about 52 in 100, in its 2020 to 2024 survey. The county's share is about 24 in 100 and Utah's about 21. Hyde Park reads level with Providence on this count, so the town is not alone in the valley.

Most of these are detached houses. About 82 in 100 homes stand alone, and the median lot is about 0.30 acre. Start with Providence homes for sale, then the two-story homes and basement homes pages.

Homes

How many Providence homes are new?

In shortAbout 12 in 100 Providence homes went up in 2020 or later, more than twice the county's share of about 5 in 100.

That share is 350 homes in the Census count, and the survey's margin is wide, so read it as somewhere between 7 and 17 in 100. County parcel records show building peaked from 2019 to 2022, with 186 homes in 2022, then 88 in 2023 and 103 in 2024.

The town's median year built is 2000, which is not newer than Smithfield's 2002, North Logan's 2005 or Nibley's 2007. At the other end, about 1 in 25 homes dates from before 1940. For new houses, see new construction homes and the guide on new construction versus resale.

Internet

Does Providence have fiber internet?

In shortYes. The city owns an open-access fiber network run by Strata Networks, and a buyer picks an internet provider from the partners on it.

Building began in 2021, and Strata calls it the first network of its kind in Cache Valley. It signed its 2,000th customer in August 2026, about 75 in 100 of the addresses it expects to serve.

Because the lines are open to several providers, a household gets two bills, one from the provider and one from the city. The city's fiber site lists 8 provider partners, and Xfinity cable and CenturyLink DSL also reach every state test point in town.

The 75 in 100 means some addresses are not connected yet, so ask about the exact address on the city's fiber site.

Nearby

How close is Providence to Logan?

In shortThe Logan city line touches Providence's north edge. From City Hall, Logan's Main and Center is about 4 minutes, Utah State about 9 and Logan Regional Hospital about 10.

These times start at the Providence City Office on Gateway Drive. About 55 in 100 workers here get to work in under 15 minutes, a bit more than the county's 49 in 100.

In town you have Macey's, the only full supermarket, with a pharmacy, plus the Megaplex. Smith's, WinCo, Costco, Target, Home Depot and Lowe's are in Logan, about 7 to 10 minutes away, and a Walmart sits about 0.6 mile from City Hall in south Logan. Route 12 runs to Logan at zero fare on weekdays and Saturdays, with no Sunday service.

Taxes

Where does Providence's city tax rate land?

In shortIn the middle of the valley's seven big cities, fourth of seven. The city's 2026 notices show no property tax increase hearing.

Nibley, Smithfield and North Logan set higher city rates for 2025, while Hyde Park, Logan and Hyrum set lower ones. The city rate pays for city operations, and fire and ambulance come from Logan City by contract.

The biggest part of a Providence bill is the Cache County School District's rate, and the district held an increase hearing on August 6, 2026. I do not have the result of that vote. The county's effective rate on a primary home runs about 0.40 percent, and sales tax is 7.30 percent from October 1, 2026. Try your own price in the property tax calculator and read Utah property taxes explained for the other lines.

Outdoors

What is at Zollinger Park?

In shortZollinger Park holds three baseball fields, four pickleball courts, three soccer and lacrosse fields and a skatepark. It is one of 11 city parks that together cover about 45 acres.

The skatepark opened on November 2, 2024. The park also has two tennis courts and sand volleyball, and dogs are not allowed.

Alma Leonhardt Park has a splash pad from Memorial Day to Labor Day. Dogs are allowed only on the Von Baer Park trail and the Brookside Park path along Spring Creek Parkway. The city has no pool, so the nearest is the Logan Aquatic Center in summer.

The Providence Canyon trailhead is 3.1 miles and about 8 minutes from City Hall; see Providence Canyon.

NextFive bedrooms, a fault and a floodway and a canyon that starts at the east tip

To weigh

Price, rentals, radon, the east edge, the creek and the pass

Things to price in or check before signing, each tied to a part of town.

Cost

What does the Census say a Providence home is worth?

In shortThe Census puts Providence's median owner estimate at $515,900, about $71,500 over Cache County's and about $132,300 over Logan's. Pay runs high too, so it is about 4.4 times household income.

Owners gave that figure when a survey asked what their home would sell for, so it is an estimate, not a sale price. Sold prices for one street are a separate record, so name the street and I can ask a local partner agent I trust to look them up.

Median household income is $118,072. That makes a home about 4.4 times a year of household pay, against 5.4 in the county and 5.1 statewide. The income figure has a wide margin, so the ratio sits somewhere between about 3.8 and 5.1, still under the county's. The value is level with North Logan's, Hyde Park's, Nibley's and Utah's.

Browse homes under $500k or homes under $750k. With the 4.4 figure in hand, test your own income in the affordability calculator.

Renting

Can you rent in Providence?

In shortYes, but few homes are rented. About 15 in 100 occupied homes in Providence are rented, against about 36 in 100 across Cache County, and the Census median rent is $1,560, about $347 over the county's.

The Census counts 409 rented homes of 2,823 occupied, so owners hold about 85 in 100. Census rent includes the basic utilities along with the payment to the landlord. At $1,560 it is about level with Utah's $1,496 and under Nibley's and North Logan's, which are both near $1,660.

Apartments and townhomes cluster in the north end. About 9 in 100 homes in town are townhome style, and about 7 in 100 sit in buildings of five units or more. See the townhomes page, and run the $1,560 median through the rent vs buy calculator.

Health

Is radon high in Providence?

In shortAbout 65 in 100 short-term radon tests in Providence's ZIP, 84332, read at or above the 4 pCi/L fix level, with an average of 8.6. The county's share is about 52 in 100.

That is 64.9 percent of 356 tests in the state's 2019 table. Millville's ZIP, at 69.4, is the only one on this page that runs higher. Hyrum reads 48.2, Logan 44.6 and Utah as a whole 35.4.

A ZIP figure blends many houses and is not a reading for one. Order a test on any home you are serious about, and read the radon guide for what a fix involves.

Ground

Where are the fault and the old slides in Providence?

In shortThe East Cache fault zone runs inside the east edge, with a state study zone over the east strip. Seven old landslides are mapped on the east hillside, and alluvial fans, ground that floods and spills debris, line the edge below the canyons.

The fault zone lies about 1.1 miles east of the Old Rock Church, and the USGS puts its slip at 0.2 to 1.0 millimeter a year. A lot in the study zone may need a fault study before building. The slides come from 1974 mapping.

This hillside is also where much of the newest building went. About 143 of the homes built since 2019 sit on it, and the acre-size lots cluster east of about 500 East. State wildlife land lies at the east boundary and national forest about a mile east, so wildfire mapping belongs in the check too.

Before an offer on the hillside, ask whether a fault study exists and have a geotechnical engineer look at the lot. The state's hazards map and the wildfire risk guide are the places to start.

Flood maps

Does Spring Creek flood?

In shortFEMA maps Spring Creek as a floodway, Zone AE, through the north-central blocks from about 300 East past Gateway Drive and City Hall to Highway 165. Zone AE also runs along the far west edge.

On the FEMA map, the floodway is the strip a flood is expected to use. The panels date to May 9, 2023. In July 2026 city staff noted wetlands, open waterways and a higher water table on the west side.

A lot near the creek or on the low west side needs a flood determination for its own address, so ask for one early in the offer.

The road south

How long is the drive from Providence to Salt Lake?

In shortSalt Lake City is about 83 miles and about 1 hour 27 minutes from Providence, over Sardine Canyon. No interstate enters Cache Valley, and no passenger train serves it.

The time starts at the City Office. Sardine Canyon is the way south: UDOT's Traction Law applies in storms, and a crash can close the road for an hour or two. The Salt Lake airport is about 90 minutes out.

Logan-Cache Airport, about 15 minutes away, has no airline flights. About 77 in 100 workers have a job outside Providence, and the average trip to work is about 18 minutes.

I am licensed in both real estate and mortgage lending. On any one purchase I serve as your agent or your lender, never both. Details on how I work.

NextMore Providence on The Local

Keep going

Continue your Providence research

HomesProvidence Homes for SaleCurrent Providence listings sort here, newest first. Set a budget, bed count, and lot size, then have a partner agent confirm the parcel before you commit.Read thisCity guideProvidence: Cost of livingProvidence costs more than much of Cache Valley. The U.S. Census puts its typical home value at about $515,900, against about $383,600 in Logan (ACS 2020-2024).Read thisCity guideProvidence: Areas and orientationProvidence reads as one town between Logan and the mountains, but the land sorts into a few distinct settings that price and live very differently.Read thisThe LocalMoving to ProvidenceA pre-purchase checklist for Providence, Utah: verify water shares, read the bench and canal drainage, confirm sewer or septic, and check school lines.Read thisThe LocalThings to DoProvidence, Utah's Old Rock Church, canyon trail, Zollinger Park and Sauerkraut Days, and splash pad, each with directions, a season and a cost.Read thisThe LocalLiving in MillvilleMillville sits under the Bear River Range on the southeast edge of Cache Valley, a residential foothill town ten minutes from Logan and Utah State.Read thisThe LocalLiving in LoganEveryday life in Logan: the USU calendar, the winter inversion and how residents cope, healthcare at Logan Regional, zero-fare transit, and the valley floor.Read thisCity guideProvidence: OverviewProvidence began in 1859 as a farm settlement called Spring Creek. That November, church leader Orson Hyde renamed it Providence.Read this
Call ScottProvidence homes