Pros and cons
Pros and cons of living in Smithfield
Smithfield's homes are a decade newer than the county's and have more rooms, at a Census value about level with the county's. Longer trips, a short frost-free season, winter air and the east-side hazard maps make up the other half.
Is Smithfield, Utah a good place to live?
The short answerA Smithfield home's Census value sits about level with the county's, while household pay runs higher. The houses are a decade newer and roomier than the county's median, and a high school, a grocery and a Forest Service canyon are all in town. Against that, trips to work run longer than the valley's, the Richmond weather station logs about three weeks less frost-free time than the Logan one, and the winter air carries the valley's F grade. The east side carries fault and wildfire mapping, about 46 in 100 radon tests ran high, and the city's own tax rate sits above most of its neighbors'.
Sky View High and three Cache County School District elementaries stand inside the city. Ratings: GreatSchools and Niche. The district redrew boundaries for 2026-27, so confirm the school for any address with the district.
The $450,200 median rests on owners' guesses on Census forms from 2020 to 2024. What a given street closed at this fall is a separate figure, and a partner agent I trust can look it up. Yard water splits the city, since about 43% of homes have no secondary connection; the rest draw from Smithfield Irrigation or a small city system (yard water answers).
The verdict
What tips toward Smithfield, and what tips away
Each line opens one question below, with the year its figure comes from.
Toward6
Away6
- A third of work trips under 15 minutes, half in the county
- Three weeks less frost-free time than Logan's station
- The valley's F air grade, read at a monitor in town
- A fault zone on the east side, a 1962 quake next door
- Radon over the action level in 46 of 100 tests
- A city rate over Logan's and Hyde Park's
Where it nets out. Newer, roomier houses at a price that tracks local pay, plus a canyon and a high school in town: that is the pull. Longer trips, spring frost, winter air, east-side maps, radon and a higher city rate are the drag. Read the drag items before you fall for the pull.
The valley table
Only Richmond's trip to work runs as long
Price and pay, the trip to work, the city rate, the hazard maps and two weather stations.
Smithfield, the county, Utah
Where Smithfield sits against the county and the state
Smithfield's median home value of $450,200 is within the margin of error of Cache County's, so call the two level. Household income is higher in Smithfield, which pulls the value to income ratio down to 4.6.
Each value above is what owners guessed on a Census form, so sale prices need a separate lookup by street.
| Measure | Smithfield | Cache County | Utah |
|---|---|---|---|
| Median home value | $450,200 | $444,400 | $489,400 |
| Median household income | $97,537 | $81,665 | $95,166 |
| Value to income | 4.6 | 5.4 | 5.1 |
| Mean trip to work (min) | 21.2 | 17.7 | 22.1 |
| Trips under 15 minutes | 33.8% | 49.3% | 32.7% |
| Median rooms | 7.6 | 6.4 | 6.4 |
| Median year built | 2002 | 1992 | 1992 |
| Built 2000 or later | 55.1% | 39.0% | 38.6% |
Local tip. Cache County's population grew about 8.9% from the 2020 base to July 2025, Utah's about 8.2% and Smithfield's about 11.7%.
Eight Cache Valley places
Nibley builds newer, Hyde Park builds bigger
North Logan, Hyde Park and Providence have higher values than Smithfield, Nibley is level with it inside the margin of error, and Logan, Richmond and Hyrum are lower.
Hyde Park (10.0 rooms) and Providence (8.5) have bigger median homes, Nibley has the newest, and Smithfield's mean trip is the longest on the list except Richmond's, which is level with it.
| Place | Home value | Value to income | Mean trip (min) | Median rooms | Median year built |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Smithfield | $450,200 | 4.6 | 21.2 | 7.6 | 2002 |
| Logan | $383,600 | 6.3 | 15.2 | 5.1 | 1984 |
| North Logan | $492,600 | 5.5 | 15.1 | 6.4 | 2005 |
| Hyde Park | $573,900 | 5.1 | 16.0 | 10.0 | 1998 |
| Richmond | $395,200 | 3.6 | 21.6 | 7.7 | 1982 |
| Providence | $515,900 | 4.4 | 17.8 | 8.5 | 2000 |
| Hyrum | $422,600 | 4.8 | 19.7 | 6.9 | 1993 |
| Nibley | $461,100 | 4.3 | 18.0 | 7.3 | 2007 |
Local tip. Logan is the only place on the list where the Census counts more rented homes than owned ones, at 37.2% owned.
Rates and hearings
Only Nibley's city rate tops Smithfield's, and the city held no 2026 hearing
Smithfield's city levy is one general-operations line on the state's 2025 report. Set beside the neighbors, it is higher than six of the seven, and only Nibley's is above it. Wellsville, Millville and River Heights, also in the county, come in below it as well.
The city adopted its 2026 budget with no property tax increase, and the state's 2026 hearing list does not include Smithfield. It does include the Cache County School District, Hyde Park, Logan, North Logan, River Heights and Wellsville. Only the city lines were compared here, so this page makes no claim about any total bill.
| Place | City rate against Smithfield's | On the 2026 hearing list |
|---|---|---|
| Smithfield | The reference | No |
| Logan | Lower | Yes |
| North Logan | Lower | Yes |
| Hyde Park | Lower | Yes |
| Providence | Lower | No |
| Richmond | Lower | No |
| Hyrum | Lower | No |
| Nibley | Higher | No |
Local tip. The Cache County School District's hearing was on August 6, 2026, and I have only the proposal, not the final vote.
The hazard maps
What the maps show, and what they leave out
Radon is reported by ZIP code. The Smithfield ZIP, 84335, ran 45.7 in 100 short-term tests at or above 4 pCi/L, under the county's 51.7 and over Utah's 35.4.
Summit Creek is a FEMA floodway, with over 200 structures in the floodplain, and a wider 500-year band runs alongside it. The state's liquefaction, shallow groundwater, collapsible soil and radon susceptibility layers are not mapped for Smithfield, which is different from a low rating. The city's plan says soils vary widely and each site should be tested on its own.
| Place | Share of tests |
|---|---|
| Smithfield, ZIP 84335 | 45.7% |
| Cache County | 51.7% |
| Utah | 35.4% |
Local tip. The 1962 quake struck at the Utah-Idaho border, and the record names Richmond, Lewiston and Logan for damage, not Smithfield.
Two stations
Two stations, two frost dates
Richmond is the station closest to Smithfield, and Utah State is the Logan one. They are two places, so a gap between them is a hint about Smithfield and not a measurement of it.
Richmond has the shorter frost-free season by about three weeks and more nights at or below zero. Its snow total is about level with Logan's, and its hot days run more often.
| Measure | Richmond station | Utah State, Logan |
|---|---|---|
| January low (F) | 16.7 | 17.6 |
| Nights at or below 32 F | About 155 | About 136 |
| Nights at or below 0 F | About 7 | About 3.6 |
| Frost-free days | 143 | 166 |
| Days at 90 F or more | About 44 | About 32 |
| Snow a year (inches) | 62.3 | 61.5 |
Local tip. Richmond logs about 44 days a year at 90 F or more, against about 32 at Utah State.
Toward
Price, house age, rooms, the school and the canyon
Six records that favor the town.
Cost
Is Smithfield cheaper than Logan or North Logan?
In shortCheaper than North Logan, Hyde Park and Providence on Census values, and dearer than Logan, Richmond and Hyrum. Against Cache County as a whole, the value is level.
For 2020 to 2024 the Census puts the median owner-estimated value at $450,200. That is about level with the county's $444,400 and about $39,200 under Utah's. Median household income is $97,537, so a home costs about 4.6 times a year of household pay, against 5.4 across the county and 5.1 statewide. The income figure has a wide margin of error, and the ratio still stays under the county's at either end of it.
Nobody paid that median, so use the listings for real prices. Browse Smithfield homes for sale, homes under $500k or homes under $600k. At 4.6 times household pay, a Smithfield price makes a fair test run for the affordability calculator with your own income.
Homes
How old are the homes in Smithfield?
In shortThe median home was built in 2002, against 1992 across Cache County. About 55 in 100 Smithfield homes date from 2000 or later.
Since 2010 alone, about 34 in 100 homes were built, against about 21 in the county, and about 7 in 100 are from 2020 or later. Nibley (median 2007) and North Logan (2005) run newer. Logan (1984), Richmond (1982), Hyrum (1993) and Hyde Park (1998) run older. These are Census figures for 2020 to 2024.
Recent builds are at new construction in Smithfield. The communities page lists the subdivisions, including Elk Ridge.
Space
Are Smithfield houses bigger than average?
In shortThe median Smithfield home has 7.6 rooms, against 6.4 in Cache County and in Utah.
The Census counts every room except baths and halls, so this is a room count and not a bedroom count. About 81 in 100 Smithfield homes are detached houses, against about 64 across the county, and the median lot is 0.28 acre. Hyde Park (10.0 rooms) and Providence (8.5) run larger, Richmond (7.7) is about level, and Logan (5.1) and North Logan (6.4) run smaller.
For a particular shape, try single-story homes, two-story homes, 3-car-garage homes or acreage homes.
In town
Is there a high school in Smithfield?
In shortYes. Sky View High is inside the city, along with three Cache County School District elementaries: Summit, Sunrise and Birch Creek.
South Main has a full grocery, Lee's Marketplace, with a pharmacy inside, and the 1921 Carnegie building still works as the library. Two hospitals sit about 9 and 11 minutes south, in North Logan and Logan. This page does not rate schools; ratings are on GreatSchools and Niche.
The library keeps Monday to Saturday hours and closes Sunday (library hours and the school table).
Outdoors
Is there hiking near Smithfield?
In shortYes. Canyon Road starts at 400 North and climbs into the Uinta-Wasatch-Cache National Forest, with Mack Park at the canyon mouth, about 3 minutes from City Hall.
Smithfield Campground is about 5 miles up, about 15 minutes from City Hall. It has 6 sites, usually opens May to September and takes reservations on Recreation.gov. Trail #007 heads toward the Mount Naomi Wilderness, designated in 1984. The gate on Canyon Road closes about December 1, and this is bear country. Cherry Peak Resort is about 18 minutes from City Hall.
More detail: the Smithfield Canyon guide and the parks and recreation guide.
Homes
How many Smithfield homes are lived in by their owners?
In shortAbout 80 in 100 occupied homes, 3,382 of 4,202, against about 64 in 100 across Cache County.
For a buyer, that means a market of mostly owner-held houses. The 820 rented homes are about 20 in 100, and about 10 in 100 homes sit in buildings of two or more units, with about 81 in 100 detached and about 9 in 100 townhome style. With 820 rentals in the whole city, a winter lease to test the town may take some searching. These are Census counts of homes for 2020 to 2024.
With 80 homes in 100 owner-held, the rent vs buy calculator is a fair way to test a lease against a purchase here.
Four doors from here
Smithfield, page by page From today's listings to the canyon road
Hub for the city, listings for today, the long guide for the year, the canyon for a day out.
Away
Trips, frost, air, the east side, radon and the city rate
Six records to settle for the exact address.
Commute
How long is the commute from Smithfield?
In shortThe Census mean trip is about 21 minutes, against about 18 across Cache County. About 34 in 100 trips take under 15 minutes, against 49 in the county.
About 10 in 100 trips take 45 minutes or more, against 7 county-wide. Utah's mean is 22.1 minutes, so by state standards Smithfield is about level, and the gap shows up against the valley. Logan (59 in 100 trips under 15 minutes) and North Logan (60) have far more short ones. About 19 in 100 Smithfield workers work from home.
Logan is about 12 minutes from City Hall. Brigham City and I-15 are about 39 minutes away over Sardine Canyon. No train runs in the valley, and FrontRunner ends at Ogden.
Weather
Is Smithfield colder than Logan?
In shortIn the frost season, the stations say so. The Richmond station near Smithfield logs about 143 frost-free days a year, against about 166 at the Logan station at Utah State.
Richmond is about 5 miles north-northeast of City Hall and about 70 feet higher, so it stands in for Smithfield without being Smithfield. It logs about 155 nights a year at or below 32 degrees, against about 136 at Utah State, and about 7 nights at or below 0, against about 3.6. The median last spring freeze is May 11 and the first fall freeze is October 5. In 1 year in 10 the last freeze comes after June 2.
Snow is about level at 62.3 inches at Richmond and 61.5 at Utah State. These are NOAA normals for 1991 to 2020. A garden here is a mid-May project (Smithfield season by season).
Air
How is the air in Smithfield?
In shortThe 2026 State of the Air report grades Cache County F for short-term particles, 24th worst in the U.S., and counts 5.8 unhealthy days a year.
Smithfield is where the valley's air gets measured. The official monitor sits at Birch Creek Elementary, so the county's ranking rests on readings taken in town. Bad winter days are fewer now: days over 50 on the air scale numbered 48 to 54 a winter from 2019-20 to 2022-23, then 21 in 2025-26, and the last three winters had none over 100.
Still, cold weather lets pollution pool on flat ground. The state posts no-burn action days, usually between November 1 and March 1, and air.utah.gov shows the day's reading.
Ground
Is there a fault line in Smithfield?
In shortYes. Mapped traces of the East Cache fault zone cross the east half of Smithfield, and the far east edge also lies inside a state study zone for surface ruptures.
USGS maps the traces as inferred, at a coarse scale, so the map cannot say which lot a trace crosses. The city's plan describes two forks along the eastern edge. On Thursday, August 30, 1962, a magnitude 5.7 earthquake struck at the Utah-Idaho border, north of Richmond, which is about 10 minutes from City Hall. The seismograph record lists severe damage in Richmond and Lewiston, and damaged waterlines and buildings in Logan.
Along that same east edge, the regional hazard plan counts 2,037 homes and 40 commercial buildings in an area it rates moderate to high for wildfire, and the edge has no secondary water storage either. Look up the lot on the state hazard map, ask whether a fault study exists and leave room for defensible space. Guides: wildfire risk in Utah and defensible space and wildfire insurance.
Health
Is radon worse in Smithfield than in the rest of Utah?
In shortSomewhat. In ZIP 84335, 45.7 of every 100 short-term tests on the state's 2019 table read 4 pCi/L or higher, a reading experts say is worth a repair.
The county as a whole ran 51.7 in 100 and Utah 35.4, so Smithfield sits under its county and over its state. The 403 tests averaged 5.8. Picocuries per liter, written pCi/L, measure the radon that seeps from soil into basements, and the number differs from house to house.
Put a radon test on the schedule before closing, and ask to see any system already installed. Guide: radon in Utah.
Taxes
Are property taxes higher in Smithfield?
In shortSmithfield's city levy sits above Logan's, North Logan's and Hyde Park's on the state's 2025 rate report. That is one line of the bill, not the whole bill.
It also sits above Providence's, Richmond's and Hyrum's, and only Nibley's is higher among the neighbors. For 2026 the city adopted its budget with no property tax increase, and Smithfield was not on the state's Truth in Taxation hearing list.
The Cache County School District, the largest line on the bill, did hold an increase hearing on August 6, 2026, as did Logan, North Logan and Hyde Park. The list marks hearings, not how any vote came out. Only Nibley levies more among the neighbors, so check that line for an address in the property tax calculator before an offer; the Utah property taxes guide explains each line.
I am licensed in both real estate and mortgage lending. On any one purchase I serve as your agent or your lender, never both. Details on how I work.
Keep going
Continue your Smithfield research
Choose your test
How late does the last frost run? Tell me where you would plant
Which month do you want to be settled, and in what part of town? The Richmond station puts the last spring freeze about May 11 and, one year in ten, after June 2. I connect you with a local partner agent I trust in the north valley. That agent's brokerage pays my brokerage a referral fee out of their commission.
Scott Buehler, REALTOR, Real Broker LLC About Scott